If I had the choice between Jamestown or Plymouth I would choose Plymouth. Plymouth would seem the best choice because they actually ended up doing pretty good. They were the first permanent english settlement in the New World. Plymouth’s first winter was harsh and many people died. After winter the few people that were alive still met a indian and his name was Squanto. He was from a very friendly tribe of indians called the Wampanoag. He taught the people in Plymouth how to grow food. After such a good harvest they decided to have a feast to say thank you to the Wampanoag.